Agriculture

Update: Stanislaus supervisors confront lack of applicants to farmworker panel

Key Takeaways
Key Takeaways

AI-generated summary reviewed by our newsroom.

Read our AI Policy.


  • Stanislaus supervisors maintain 10 worker seats despite no applications so far.
  • Recruitment likely hindered by deportation fears among undocumented workers.
  • Board filled roles for grower, labor contractor, and two farmworker nonprofits.

Stanislaus County will keep recruiting for its new Farm Worker Advisory Committee, despite zero applications so far from the laborers.

The Board of Supervisors voted 5-0 on Tuesday, July 22, to keep the number of worker seats at 10. Agricultural Commissioner Linda Pinfold had suggested trimming it to five to get the panel going sooner.

The board also began filling some of the other seats, including a farm owner, a labor contractor and two nonprofits that advocate for workers.

JBL Peaches Weather 2
From left, Beatriz Castillo, Juan Romero, Manuel Baldovenas and Cynthia Cortez work the 2014 peach harvest just north of Modesto, Calif. Joan Lee jlee@modbee.com

Supervisors created the committee last November, after complaints that the workers deserve more recognition and assistance.

Advocates told The Modesto Bee last week that the recruitment has been stymied by President Donald Trump’s call for mass deportations. They say most of the workers are undocumented but are crucial to the massive food and beverage industries in Stanislaus.

The committee is to be a one-year pilot program, with up to six meetings to discuss pay, housing, health care and other needs. Members would meet in public, with translation between English and Spanish, and receive $100 stipends per session.

The committee will have two workers from each of the five supervisor districts. The initial proposal in November was one per district.

Supervisor Channce Condit said Tuesday that having 10 rather than five would best serve the workers.

“We have to have their voice and their input and their insight, and that at the root of it all is the core purpose of this committee,” he said.

Interested people can apply on the ag commissioner’s website. The deadline had been extended a few times, most recently to July 15. The new deadline was not announced.

Workers harvest green kale at Ratto Bros. farm west of Modesto, Calif., on Friday, July 24, 2020.
Workers harvest green kale at Ratto Bros. farm west of Modesto, Calif., on Friday, July 24, 2020. Andy Alfaro aalfaro@modbee.com

Who has been appointed to committee so far?

Supervisors took these other actions on the committee:

  • Filled the farm owner seat with Anthony Ratto, operations manager for Ratto Bros., a longtime grower and processor of fresh vegetables west of Modesto.
  • Appointed Benjamin Lopez of Salida to the labor contractor seat. Many farmers use these parties to hire crews. The contractors are licensed by the state and must follow rules on pay, safety and other concerns.
  • Named two people from nonprofit groups that advocate for farmworkers, up from one under the initial plan at Supervisor Mani Grewal’s urging. One appointee is Noé Páramo, director of the sustainable rural communities project at California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation. The other is Jose Moreno, vice president for operations at El Concilio California.
  • Postponed filling the seat for a member of the Stanislaus County Agricultural Advisory Board, which is made up of farmers and leaders with local, state and federal agencies involved in various aspects of food production. The group has not yet decided on its nominee to the farmworker committee.

All of Tuesday’s appointments were unanimous except for the two nonprofits serving farmworkers. Supervisor Buck Condit said he preferred to have just one.

Maria Castillo calls out to motorists during a United Farm Workers rally in Ceres calling on Gov. Newsom to support the Agricultural Labor Relations Voting Choice Act which would allow farm workers to vote by mail in union elections. Photographed on Hatch Road in Ceres, Calif., on Thursday, March 31, 2022.
Maria Castillo calls out to motorists during a United Farm Workers rally in Ceres calling on Gov. Newsom to support the Agricultural Labor Relations Voting Choice Act which would allow farm workers to vote by mail in union elections. Photographed on Hatch Road in Ceres, Calif., on Thursday, March 31, 2022. Andy Alfaro aalfaro@modbee.com

This story was originally published July 23, 2025 at 6:17 PM.

John Holland
The Modesto Bee
John Holland covers agriculture, transportation and general assignment news. He has been with The Modesto Bee since 2000 and previously worked at newspapers in Sonora and Visalia. He was born and raised in San Francisco and has a journalism degree from UC Berkeley.
Get unlimited digital access
#ReadLocal

Try 1 month for $1

CLAIM OFFER