Anyone inclined to high-five the dismissal of chairwoman Felicia Marcus from the State Water Resources Control Board should put their hands to better use. Like using them to roll up their sleeves so we can get to work fixing our rivers and making them more hospitable to salmon.
Marcus’s replacement was announced in Gov. Gavin Newsom’s first State of the State speech, Tuesday. He elevated Joaquin Esquivel to the chair.
He also laid out an incredibly ambitious – and exciting – plan to make California a better place to live. Newsom will downsize the California WaterFix from two tunnels to one, focus the state’s high-speed rail project on the Central Valley, elevate dealing with homelessness to a moral imperative, and try to make certain everyone in our state can afford a place to live and has clean water to drink.
Dismissing Marcus was necessary after she led the board to a 4-1 vote implementing Phase I of the Bay-Delta Plan. Phase I focused on the San Joaquin River – and its biggest tributaries, the Tuolumne, Merced and Stanislaus rivers – which provides about 20 percent of the Delta’s flows. The other 80 percent come from the Sacramento.
Phase I would double flows dedicated for fish, requiring the fallowing thousands of acres in Stanislaus, Merced and San Joaquin counties, costing of tens of millions of dollars.
In its December vote, the board set aside the mandatory requirement that decisions be based on the “best available science,” relying instead on 10-, 20- or 30-year-old studies. More up-to-date studies were ignored, as were significant improvements in salmon survival.
The vote also ignored a plea from Newsom and former Gov. Jerry Brown to allow our region’s water districts and the state to reach “voluntary settlements.”
The state already had such a deal on the Tuolumne, promising creation of flood plains, better spawning beds and strategically increased flows. A similar deal on the Stanislaus River was close.
Voting to implement Phase I ended those negotiations, but gave birth to a litter of lawsuits involving Modesto, Turlock, Oakdale, Merced and South San Joaquin irrigation districts. The California Farm Bureau, city of Modesto and City and County of San Francisco also sued. So did environmental groups.
Replacing Marcus will create a better environment for resumed talks.
It also validates the approach taken by Michael Frantz of Turlock and John Mensinger of Modesto irrigation districts; of Stanislaus supervisors Vito Chiesa and Terry Withrow, and others. All recognize that salmon should be saved, and the sacrifices necessary to do it.
They also know that even if thousands of salmon swim down our rivers, few will survive the Delta – an ecosystem degraded by generations of diking and dredging and infested by predatory bass. Some years, 100 percent of juvenile salmon die in the Delta.
Gavin Newsom has a vision for our state that is at once dramatic and pragmatic. We like it. But nothing about his vision is more important than solving our water problems.
“Let me be direct,” said Newsom, taking on the state’s “massive” water challenges. “The status quo is not an option.”
Marcus represented that status quo. But anyone who sees her dismissal as some sort of victory is wrong. What the governor has given us is an opportunity to go back to work; to find a way to equitably restore and share our rivers.
Without salmon, our rivers are ruined. Without farming, our lives are ruined. Our new governor wants us to figure out how best to save both.