Opinion articles provide independent perspectives on key community issues, separate from our newsroom reporting.

Opinion Columns & Blogs

Doing away with long commutes in post-COVID new normal

I must admit to a strong bias. I am old fashioned. I believe in going into the office, and appreciate the routine of rising early in the morning, drinking coffee, joining the flow of people commuting to work and retreating to my home sanctuary after a hard day’s work.

Now, I work where I live, and for the first time I conducted the business of being a legislator not from the Capitol dome in Sacramento, but from my home in Salinas.

Recently, I remotely participated in the first Senate Budget Subcommittee hearing on the COVID-19 pandemic. More than 10,000 Californians streamed the hearing and provided public comment over the phone.

This was the return to democracy in the COVID era. This is the new normal. Being a part of this historic event, I challenged my own bias against working from home. I have been doing it now since the governor’s orders, my staff is performing amazing things working from home, as so many other Californians are.

I am seeing positives emerge from the stay-at-home orders. Wildlife across the planet is stretching its legs, less inhibited from the hustle and bustle of humanity. Air pollution is plummeting in some of the most polluted cities. People are walking, biking, running, reading, talking with family, and while physically distancing, they are attending video happy hours, concerts and more. Most humans are proving their resiliency.

The impacts of work where you live, don’t live where you work started to swirl in my head.

I have been thinking about what that could mean for Modesto, Ceres, Los Banos, Merced and the Central Valley. I started to think about communities like Westley, Patterson and more that used to be rural, but are now overrun by Silicon Valley super-commuters.

These residents are paid Silicon Valley wages and make commuter-based bedroom communities out of rural areas. They fulfill their lives and build social networks where they work because of the requirement to commute into the office day after day after day.

Policymakers in California accept office space working, likely, because we all harbor that old-fashioned bias. We pass legislation to encourage housing development along public transit in urban areas on the premise that this will reduce transportation-based emissions from super-commuters.

When the pandemic started, institutions of higher education and high tech employers immediately acted on data and changed how they operated. So, I put these questions to the leading employers in Silicon Valley: Is there anything that prevents the tens of thousands of people from doing that job remotely from Patterson, Gustine or Modesto?

Think of the local sales and property tax coffers for rural communities, if the high-tech workforce smartly distributed itself across California. Think of college graduates that could return to their rural communities and bring home an influx of intellectual capital and income. Broadband internet infrastructure would be as ubiquitous as water and energy. Small businesses and health care services would grow, as per capita income increases. These residents would be part of a community, instead of spending their family and free time in pollution-causing commutes.

Everything we are doing at the state government level now is through the lens of COVID-19. We have changed how we work, but we must also change our approach to solving global issues like climate change and the digital divide.

We can sit idly by, blind to the lessons that this pandemic puts before our eyes. Or we can wake up to the new normal, and plan for a virtual future, where online commerce, tele-health, tele-education and more are equally available to anyone anywhere.

The push to have workers commute to a job each day creates massive health and societal strains. A commitment to the new normal would push broadband everywhere, finally. It would decrease transportation-based climate pollution, freeing hundreds of billions of dollars in government programs for investments in health and education, literally making communities stronger and smarter.

The only thing holding us back from this better, new future are our old biases.

State Sen. Anna Caballero, a Democrat from Salinas, represents the 12th State Senate District, which includes part of Stanislaus County. She wrote this commentary for CalMatters, a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s Capitol works and why it matters.



This story was originally published May 21, 2020 at 5:00 AM.

Get unlimited digital access
#ReadLocal

Try 1 month for $1

CLAIM OFFER