Games of Risk
02/04/2014 2:31 PM
02/04/2014 2:32 PM
Olympian Roberto Carcelen wouldn’t be competing in Sochi if it weren’t for his wife, Kate. She was the one who introduced him to skiing after he gave up elite surfing in Peru to move to Seattle and marry her. She convinced him that it was like surfing on frozen water.
When Carcelen skis for his native Peru on the cross-country track this month, however, Kate and their daughter will be at home. Amid reports about the possibility of terrorist attacks at the Winter Games, they decided it would be safer – and less stressful.
“I’m going to be up training in the mountains, while the family would be down in the city outside the Olympic rink,” Carcelen told CNN. “So that puts a lot of pressure on me as an athlete.”
The security threat during the Olympics isn’t hypothetical. As has been widely reported, the Winter Games site is in a country with an active insurgency capable of coordinating devastating attacks. In the past seven months, Chechen terrorists have twice issued statements targeting the Olympics. But if there’s a terrorist attack during the Games, it’s far more likely to happen outside Sochi.
That’s because President Vladimir Putin has gone all out to secure the Olympic villages and venues. His “ring of steel” includes 100,000 police officers, soldiers and secret service personnel; drones and attack helicopters; and advanced ground-to-air missile systems. Russia’s surveillance state will be in full force, operating tens of thousands of security cameras and monitoring phone calls and emails. Visitors to the Olympic Villages will have to show pre-approved “Olympic passports.”
While the Olympic sites will be brimming with security, much more vulnerable are the routes in and out of Sochi. Attacks on transportation are the signature of Russia’s current terrorist nemesis, the Caucasus Emirate. It claimed responsibility for derailing a high-speed train in 2009, sending a pair of female suicide bombers to strike Moscow’s metro during rush hour in 2010 and targeting Russia’s largest airport in 2011. It has also targeted security checkpoints, and there will be many on the road to Sochi.
The group might figure that an attack at such a checkpoint, on a bus or on the railroad tracks would have the same symbolic effect as striking within Sochi.
Air is the most defensible route to the Winter Games, and it’s how the majority of the 15,000 Americans will get there. One can fly into the newly expanded Sochi-Adler International Airport from Frankfurt, Istanbul, Munich, Moscow, St. Petersburg and several smaller Russian cities. Russia’s airports, with their guns, gates and guards, should be relatively safe. But the planes are vulnerable to shoulder-fired missiles, a weapon terrorist groups have used to target civilian aircraft. Ominously, Russia in 2012 discovered large weapons caches near Sochi that included several such missiles.
On the ground, bus and rail are the primary travel options. Sochi hugs the Black Sea for 92 miles, and there are only two main arteries into the city: one highway and one rail line. By road, the nearest intersection is 100 miles northwest of Sochi along the winding M27 highway, through villages and mountain switchbacks. As of Jan. 7, drivers with out-of-town license plates have had to leave their cars 60 miles away and take shuttle buses in.
The rail line winds up the coast some 75 miles to the town of Tuapse, then splits off through mountains and into one of Europe’s largest primeval forests. Beyond that, a spider web of transport hubs, connecting railways, and sleepy stops in towns and tiny villages links Fortress Sochi to the city of Krasnodar and the rest of the world. Of course, Winter Games are often in hard-to-reach mountain towns, but the journey to Lake Placid, Nagano or Lillehammer did not wind through terrorist haunts.
Both of these fragile ground-transport ribbons are vulnerable. A well-placed obstruction on a hairpin turn would delay traffic for hours. Combined with a terror strike, it would decimate any sense of safety, cast a pall over Sochi and shake Putin’s image as a man with an iron grip. Blast roadways and train tracks simultaneously, and one of the largest sporting events in Russia’s history becomes a disaster.
Russian and U.S. security officials are aware of these vulnerabilities. Russia has informally requested use of the Pentagon’s sophisticated anti-bomb equipment to suppress threats along the roads and rails. Meanwhile, Matthew Olsen, director of the National Counterterrorism Center, told the Senate last week that the greatest threat to the Games is terrorists hitting “softer targets” around Sochi. The State Department has warned athletes to avoid wearing Team USA gear outside of Olympic venues. The U.S. military has positioned two naval ships in the Black Sea and has aircraft on standby in Germany in case it needs to evacuate Americans quickly.
The Olympics’ Closing Ceremonies on Feb. 23 coincide with the 70th anniversary of Stalin’s brutal deportation of the Chechen and Ingush populations from the Caucasus. Almost 500,000 men, women and children were rounded up in freight trains and sent to Central Asia. Up to half of them perished along the way. Terrorists might try to exploit the symbolism of the day and of the Olympics for nefarious ends, and transportation in and out of the Games may be the place they’ll choose to make their presence known.
Let’s hope we remember the Sochi Games for the triumph of the athletes, not of the terrorists.
The Washington Post
Editor's Choice Videos
Join the Discussion
The Modesto Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.