Malibu Hubrid is slowly trickling in to dealers
06/06/2008 11:30 AM
06/06/2008 11:48 AM
The largest mainstream gas/electric hybrid car on the U.S. market isn't a Toyota or a Honda.
It's the new-for-2008, family-size Chevrolet Malibu Hybrid, which stretches 16 feet from bumper to bumper, has a roomy, midsize sedan trunk and carries more than 16 gallons of gasoline.
Best of all, the five-passenger Malibu Hybrid offers the top fuel economy of all Malibus — a federal government rating of 24 miles per gallon in city driving and 32 mpg on the highway.
The hybrid car with a larger exterior is the 2008 Lexus LS 600h L, but at more than $104,000, the LS 600h L luxury sedan is hardly "mainstream."
In contrast, Chevrolet's hybrid version of the Malibu has a starting manufacturer's suggested retail price, including destination charge, of $24,290. Unfortunately, today's MSRP, plus destination charge, for the Malibu Hybrid — already increased from the original $22,790 starting price — no longer makes the Malibu Hybrid the lowest-priced gas/electric hybrid on the market, as officials at Chevrolet's parent company, General Motors Corp., had hoped.
Both the 2008 Toyota Prius, which starts at $23,135, and 2008 Honda Civic Hybrid, which starts at $23,235, have starting retail prices that are lower than that of the Malibu Hybrid.
Add in delays in getting appreciable numbers of Malibu Hybrids out to dealers — caused in part by leaking nickel-metal-hydride battery packs on earlier GM hybrid vehicles — and the fact the Malibu Hybrid doesn't have all the hybrid features of Toyota and Honda vehicles, and you can see why fewer than 800 Malibu Hybrids have been sold so far.
The leaking battery pack was "a battery supplier issue," according to Chevrolet spokeswoman Nancy Libby, and has been corrected.
But because new battery packs had to be diverted for installation in 2007 Saturn Vue and Aura hybrids with the problem, Malibu Hybrid production for the 2008 model year did not crank up for the numbers planned.
The test hybrid had the clean, pleasing looks of all 2008 Malibus. Styling inside and out is modern, without being gimmicky.
On the outside, the only thing that noticeably distinguishes the hybrid model from nonhybrid Malibus is the hybrid badging.
Inside, the Malibu Hybrid doesn't have the eye-catching energy display — complete with a diagram of a car — that the Prius typically has. The reason: The Malibu doesn't have a full hybrid system, one that can propel a vehicle for a certain distance at times on electric power only.
Rather, it is a "mild" hybrid whose fuel savings come primarily from the ability of the four-cylinder engine to turn itself off automatically when the car is stopped at traffic lights and stop signs and cued up at school loading zones.
Thankfully, there's an "auto stop" light that comes on in the instrument cluster at these times so the driver knows the car is still OK and hasn't stalled or quit working.
But with the engine off, the Malibu isn't using gasoline, resulting in improved fuel mileage.
The 2.4-liter, double overhead cam, Ecotec four cylinder starts up on its own the instant a driver begins to lift a foot from the brake pedal.
But be aware that some drivers may need to change their driving styles. I tend to try to stop a vehicle smoothly, but my gentle brake pedal movement often didn't initiate the engine shut-off in the test car. The Malibu Hybrid's regenerative braking also kicked in and would alter my planned braking distance.
I discovered I could get the engine to shut off when I pushed sharply on the brake pedal, but then the Malibu Hybrid stopped more abruptly than I liked.
Don't worry that on hot summer days, passengers will swelter in a car whose engine turns off automatically. The Malibu Hybrid monitors air conditioning needs and in the test car readily started up the engine even at stoplights when cool air was needed.
Too bad, though, that the start-up often felt rough and unrefined — like a car dieseling and trying not to stall.
There's generous room in the back seat of the Malibu Hybrid. I could sit there, with a front seat up a ways on its track, and stretch my legs. Seats were comfortable, and the built-in, nonadjustable back-seat head restraints appeared to be positioned well for all kinds of passengers.
Rear-seat headroom of 37.2 inches, however, is a tad less than what's in the Prius, Civic Hybrid and Toyota Camry Hybrid.
Rear-door openings on the Malibu Hybrid are good-sized, and the test car rode smoothly over most roads.
The 164-horsepower four cylinder, with a maximum torque of 159 foot- pounds at 4,400 rpm, got buzzy in demanding acceleration, and I needed a good amount of room to pass other vehicles.
At 3,537 pounds, the Malibu Hybrid is 605 pounds heavier than the Prius. And, in contrast with the Prius and Civic Hybrid, there was no gratifying "oomph" from electric-motor torque in the Malibu.
The Malibu Hybrid also has an unwieldy turning circle of 40.4 feet. This compares with 34.1 feet in the Prius.
In combined city and highway travel, I managed 25.7 mpg. Even the Malibu Hybrid's government rating of 24/32 mpg is less than those of the Prius, Camry Hybrid and Civic Hybrid, which have full hybrid systems.
Six air bags, anti-lock brakes, traction control and stability control are among the Malibu's standard features. The 2008 Malibu Hybrid earned across-the-board five-out-of-five-stars ratings in frontal and side crash testing, according to the federal government.
OnStar, an emergency notification system, also is standard and is something not on the Honda and Toyota hybrids.
A final note: There is a $1,300 U.S. tax credit available on the Malibu Hybrid. It doesn't come at the time of purchase and isn't cash. But buyers can document their purchase to reduce their 2008 federal income taxes by $1,300. Taxpayers subject to alternative minimum tax may not qualify.
Join the Discussion
The Modesto Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.