Mostly cloudy. Highs 54 to 62. Light winds becoming  northwest 5 to 10 mph in the afternoon.

Modesto, CA
Overcast, 56°
Hi/Low: 58° / 40°
Extended forecast

Click here to register for a free car wash!
Search for
Web search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
Business

Sunday, Mar. 16, 2008

Utilities, consumers face challenges presented by renewable energy

email this story to a friend E-Mail print story Print
Comments (0)
Text Size:

tool name

close
tool goes here

It's still winter, but Charles and Bonnie Evers are seeing just how powerful the sun can be.

The Modesto residents have a new solar electricity system that produces more than their home consumes this time of year.

Their surplus goes onto the Modesto Irrigation District's grid. In exchange, they get credits for conventional power they might need during high summer demand.

  • At a glance

  • THE MANDATE: Electric utilities in California have to boost their use of renewable energy to 20 percent of the total supply. Large hydroelectric plants, such as those on the Tuolumne and Stanislaus rivers, do not count. Solar, wind and geothermal do. So do farm wastes, such as pruned tree limbs and methane from manure.
  • PROS: Renewable energy reduces pollution and could help avert global warming. It also keeps money in the local economy and reduces dependence on petroleum from the Middle East and other unstable regions.
  • CONS: Renewable energy can be expensive. Solar and wind are intermittent sources. Wind turbines on Altamont Pass have killed birds.
  • Solar advice

  • Have an expert determine how much unshaded area is available for a collector on your roof.
  • Use energy-efficient appliances to reduce the size of the solar system needed.
  • Check on the solar installer's license and references.
  • If money is tight, consider a partial system. This will at least reduce electricity used in the higher billing tiers, which costs more per kilowatt-hour.
  • More information

  • California Solar Initiative
  • Solar Electric Power Association:
  • U.S. Department of Energy:
  • Summary of renewable energy incentives
  • "It's nice to see the meter run in reverse," said Charles Evers, whose $30,000 system was among the first enrolled in the MID's new solar program.

    This is just one of the ways that renewable energy is taking hold in California. Utilities also are offering substantial rebates on the cost of installing home solar systems. And they are looking to large, centralized projects that tap sunlight, wind and other alternative sources for their customers.

    The goal is to reduce the burning of fossil fuels, which are believed to increase the level of carbon dioxide and other climate-changing gases in the atmosphere.

    "To me, one of the big things is you're cleaning up the air," Evers said. "I'm definitely into the green stuff. I've got two Toyota Priuses."

    State lawmakers have mandated that renewables, which were 11 percent of the electricity supply in 2006, rise to 20 percent in the next decade. Some are calling for 33 percent or even 50 percent.

    Doing this will take money, whether for solar collectors on home rooftops or the large projects that the MID, the Turlock Irrigation District and other utilities are pursuing.

    MID officials said all the options -- including solar, wind, geothermal, biomass and manure -- will cost more than the hydroelectric and natural-gas plants that predominate today.

    The renewable mandate could add 20 percent to 30 percent to MID customer bills on top of inflation, said Greg Salyer, manager of resource planning and development, during a board meeting last week.

    As of now, 12 percent of MID power is renewable, most of it from wind turbines in Solano County and Washington state.

    The district is a few months away from hooking into a system at Fiscalini Cheese Co. that will burn methane derived from cow manure.

    The options include burning methane extracted from sewage treatment or landfills, or using the huge amount of limbs pruned from the area's orchards each year.

    There are caveats. Biomass -- woody material from orchard pruning, forest thinning and construction sites -- can be expensive to transport and unavailable during parts of the year. Solar and wind produce only when it's sunny or windy.

    Solar installers expected price drop

    Jim Metropulos, a renewable energy advocate with the Sierra Club in Sacramento, acknowledged the challenges. But he said new taxes might be imposed on fossil fuels to discourage consumption, making renewables more attractive.

    "It makes sense if the cost of carbon emissions is taken into account," he said.

    Richard Harriman, a Modesto attorney who advocates for MID ratepayers, told the board that the cost of solar systems will drop as they are produced in larger numbers.

    "If we drive that process, we can get it to happen sooner," he said.

    Solar installers said they expected the cost to drop, but this hasn't happened. They blame the rising cost of copper wire and other components, along with the willingness of Europeans to pay high prices for the systems.

    But even with this, solar makes sense, the installers said. Rebates can knock out a quarter to a third of the typical cost. Then there's a $2,000 federal tax credit.

    Quick Job Search