OUR VIEW

Our View: Central Valley has the greatest need for using “cap and trade” billions

May 1, 2014 

DN Bad air alert

Busy Highway 99 with downtown Modesto at the horizon in a haze Monday Aug. 19, 2013. An Air Alert for Monday through Wednesday for Stanislaus county and other counties in the valley basin was announced by the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution control district for potential ozone buildup that could exceed health-based ozone standard.

DEBBIE NODA — Modesto Bee Buy Photo

There’s no shortage of ideas on how to spend California’s anticipated “cap and trade” billions.

But two recent reports lay out a compelling case for where a serious dose of that money, from the state’s program to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, needs to go.

Last week, in an eye-opening map of communities most wracked by pollution, the California Environmental Protection Agency left no doubt that the Central Valley is by far the state’s biggest and most vulnerable environmental challenge. Color-coded from green to hazardous red to pinpoint areas with the greatest exposure to contaminated air, soil and water, the CalEnviroScreen map featured a big, crimson welt at the state’s very core, festering from West Sacramento to Bakersfield.

The California EPA data looked at environmental risks and human demographics. By any measure, however, it was clear that the region’s longstanding problems are shortening millions of lives.

In the worst tract, 3,000 men, women and children in West Fresno were breathing exhaust from three freeways, fumes from a rendering plant and a meat-processing plant, and tending fields that ranked in the 90th percentile for pesticide applications.

Conditions weren’t much healthier in the surrounding counties, a point driven home by the second study, released Wednesday by the American Lung Association. That report focused on levels of particulates and ozone. It found, for the third year in a row, that the Central Valley had the most polluted air in the nation, and that wasn’t even counting the later months of last year when air quality plummeted amid winter heat waves and drought. Four of the top five in both categories were in that same area – Bakersfield to Sacramento.

Fresno, with its sooty air, had more particulates than any other American city, with Visalia-Porterville-Hanford and Bakersfield right behind it. Modesto and Merced, as a single region, ranked fifth on the list.

The Central Valley’s topography and climate pose a challenge. Surrounded by mountains, the region is a hot, massive sink that traps pollution and bakes it. Pollution from the Bay Area blows in through the Altamont pass – a low gap in the Coastals – to inflict us with even more ozone and particulates.

But more can surely be done about the man-made parts of its problems – the old fleets of farm equipment, the big-rig exhaust from Highway 99 and Interstate 5, the agribusiness pollution, the cultural and economic reliance on gas guzzlers.

Although California has so many electric vehicles now that the state has had to look at narrowing the requirements for the $2,500 rebates it offers, only 2 percent of those rebates have gone to owners of cars in the San Joaquin Valley.

The cap-and-trade fees California hopes to collect from factories, food processors, oil companies and other big polluters could make a difference. By law, a quarter of that money must go to “disadvantaged” communities. Having the worst air in the nation should count as a substantial disadvantage.

As lawmakers debate grand plans, from high-speed rail to transit-oriented housing, they should keep in mind that the money derived from this tax must be focused on projects that will benefit the most affected.

Politicians from across the state must recognize that a pollution-steeped red zone with asthma rates that are triple the national average is a national embarrassment we can no longer tolerate.

Modesto Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service