Our View: Boehner should bring immigration reform to a vote now

December 2, 2013 

Speaker of the House John Boehner (R-Ohio) speaks at a press conference in September.


While we were enjoying our Thanksgiving Day meals, there were people on the National Mall fasting to highlight the cause of immigration reform.

Their target: House Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio. If he would bring the Senate’s bipartisan immigration reform bill to a vote in the House, it would likely pass.

A great many (not all) Republicans and most (not all) Democrats support immigration reform. This is an issue that has broad support. But Boehner has made it abundantly clear that he is not looking for a majority vote. He will bring legislation to the floor only if it has a majority of Republican votes.

Boehner should remember that the office of speaker is in the U.S. Constitution. He is supposed to represent the House as a whole, not just the Republican caucus – or the small tea party faction in the Republican caucus.

The Senate passed a bipartisan immigration package (S.744) on a 68-32 vote in June.

Some House Republicans have made noises about passing piecemeal immigration reform legislation to send over to the Senate. But they don’t really want reform. They refuse to allow a House-Senate conference committee even to consider the Senate’s bill, which is at least a fair starting point.

Boehner went along with that: “I’ll make clear that we have no intention of ever going to conference on the Senate bill.”

Will not even negotiate, even with many – such as Rep. Jeff Denham – in his own party.

On Nov. 21, Boehner said immigration reform was “absolutely not” a dead issue. Yet he has scheduled only eight days of work in the House for December, promising to go home on Dec. 13 for the year, with no date for a vote on immigration reform.

Just bring S.744 to the House floor for a vote and see if a majority supports it. If it fails, then do something else.

President Barack Obama was in San Francisco just before Thanksgiving and spoke about the bureaucratic mess of the current immigration system. He noted that it drives illegal immigration: “I hear from folks who have been separated from their families for years because of green card backlogs who desperately want their loved ones to be able to join them here in America. I hear from young DREAMers who are Americans through and through in every way but on paper, and they just want a chance to study and serve and contribute to the nation that they love.”

Americans understand this and they want action. Many sympathize with the young man who shouted during Obama’s speech, “Mr. Obama, my family has been separated for 19 months now!”

The president made a plea: “What I’ve said to the speaker and others is, don’t let a minority of folks block something that the country desperately needs. We can’t leave this problem for another generation to solve. If we don’t tackle this now, then we’re undercutting our own future.”

California has a huge stake in reforming the immigration system. As the California Chamber of Commerce and more than 40 local chambers wrote in a letter to members of Congress earlier this year, “resolving the immigration status of 2.6 million California residents would unlock billions of dollars of consumer spending and investment and help the state recover from the lingering effects of the recession.”

This is yet another test of whether majorities, or a tea party minority, rule in the House. Immigration reform can pass by Boehner’s Dec. 13 deadline if he will just bring it to a vote.

Modesto Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service