Feds went too far in taking AP records


May 14, 2013 

Protecting national security is one thing. Fishing expeditions that could intimidate and impede important watchdog reporting are another matter entirely.

The Justice Department certainly appears to have gone too far in trying to ferret out who leaked information on a secret CIA operation that foiled an al-Qaida plot to bomb a U.S.-bound airliner last year around the first anniversary of the killing of Osama bin Laden.

According to The Associated Press, federal prosecutors seized phone records for April and May 2012 not only from the reporters and editor involved in that story, but from more than 20 phone lines in the news cooperative's offices in Washington, D.C., New York and Hartford, Conn., as well as several of their personal phones.

While the records would not divulge what was said during the calls, they would show the phone numbers of people or agencies the reporters called, potentially including whistleblowers and confidential sources. The AP is right in calling the sweeping dragnet an unjustified and unprecedented intrusion into its newsgathering. All Americans ought to be alarmed.

It is yet another scandalous distraction in the early months of President Barack Obama's second term. The White House can try to distance itself and claim that Obama believes strongly in an unfettered press, as spokesman Jay Carney repeatedly did Tuesday under withering questioning from the press corps.

But when the president has bragged about how aggressively his administration has gone after national security leaks — "zero tolerance," he has said — it doesn't wash.

During Obama's first term, the Justice Department prosecuted six former and current government officials under the 1917 Espionage Act. Under all previous presidents, there were only three such prosecutions. Some cases carried over from the Bush administration, there has been bipartisan support for a tougher stance after 9-11, and technology makes it easier to track emails, phone calls and other communications. Still, the Justice Department has to decide to pursue the cases. The one involving the airliner plot is one of at least two being investigated. The AP story, published last May, reported that al-Qaida operatives had devised a bomb that would not contain metal to evade airport security, and that the CIA seized it before tickets had been bought.

Attorney General Eric Holder, who announced in June that he had appointed a U.S. attorney to investigate the leak, called it one of the most serious he has seen. "It put the American people at risk — that is not hyperbole," he told reporters Tuesday.

Holder said prosecutors have followed all department rules. Among them is that phone records from news organizations can be subpoenaed only after "all reasonable attempts" have been made to get the same information from other sources.

The Obama administration is telling Americans to trust its assurances that seizing so many phone records from so many reporters was proper and necessary. That's a lot to ask.

Modesto Bee is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service